Skip to content

Market appraisal vs valuation

A market appraisal is an agent’s advice on the price to market at. A valuation is a formal report by a RICS Registered Valuer that lenders, courts and HMRC can rely on.

Opens a sample report to look around. No account needed.

Five lines that keep an agent’s letter in its lane

Agents and the public often call the appraisal visit a valuation. The word is not the problem. A letter that looks like a formal valuation without being one is. These lines go at the foot of any appraisal letter.

Replace each item in square brackets.

At the foot of your letter
  1. Status

    Say what the document is and is not.

    This is a marketing appraisal, not a RICS Red Book valuation.

  2. Purpose

    Name the client and limit who may rely on it.

    It has been prepared for [client name] to decide on a marketing price and should not be relied on by any other person or for any other purpose.

  3. Validity

    A stated period from the date of the letter.

    All values presented are valid for a period of [validity period] from the date of this letter.

  4. Inspection

    What was not done.

    I have not carried out a survey, tested services or inspected the title.

  5. No guarantee

    That the price achieved may differ.

    The price achieved will depend on the market at the time and on the buyer’s own enquiries.

Draft an appraisal that states plainly what it is.

The difference at a glance

QuestionMarket appraisalValuation
Who carries it outAn estate or letting agentA RICS Registered Valuer
What it answersWhat price to market at and howWhat the property is worth on a stated basis and date
StandardThe agent’s judgement and comparable evidenceRICS Valuation: Global Standards, known as the Red Book
ResultA recommended asking price, often with alternativesA single reported value
Who relies on itThe vendor or landlordLenders, courts, HMRC and other third parties
Usual cost to the clientUsually noneA fee agreed with the surveyor

Which one each purpose needs

PurposeDocumentNotes
Deciding an asking priceMarket appraisalSee the estate agent valuation letter template
Setting a rentRental appraisalSee the rental valuation letter template
Mortgage lendingValuationThe lender instructs its own valuer
Probate and Inheritance TaxEither, depending on the estateAn agent’s opinion may be enough for a simple estate. See the probate valuation letter template
Divorce and court proceedingsValuationCourts usually expect an independent expert
Shared ownership staircasing or lease extensionValuationThe lease or the landlord will usually require a RICS valuer

Where DemandMap sits

DemandMap is on the appraisal side of the line. Its Property reports tool reads a Rightmove Best Price Guide and supporting files, proposes marketing prices from the comparables and drafts a letter for the agent to review, edit and sign. It does not produce a Red Book valuation and no figure is final until the agent approves it.

Every letter it drafts carries the status line and a validity note, as in the example at the top of this page. The market appraisal letter page gives the pricing wording that sits above these caveats.

Questions agents ask

Is a market appraisal the same as a valuation?
No. A market appraisal is an agent’s advice on a marketing price. A valuation is a formal report by a RICS Registered Valuer on a stated basis of value, prepared under the Red Book.
Is a letter drafted in DemandMap a RICS valuation?
No. It is a marketing appraisal, not a RICS Red Book valuation, and every letter says so.
Can an estate agent carry out a valuation?
An estate agent can give a market appraisal. Only an agent who is also a RICS Registered Valuer can provide a Red Book valuation.
Is a market appraisal accepted for a mortgage?
No. A mortgage lender instructs its own valuation and does not rely on the selling agent’s appraisal.
Why can an appraisal and a valuation give different figures?
They answer different questions. An appraisal recommends a price to attract buyers and may sit above or below the figure a valuer reports for a lender on a fixed basis and date.
What is a Red Book valuation?
A valuation carried out by a RICS Registered Valuer in line with RICS Valuation: Global Standards, which set out the basis of value, the inspection and the content of the report.

Prepare a marketing appraisal

Open the sample report to see the letter and its caveats, then upload your own Best Price Guide.

Draft an appraisal that states plainly what it is.

Try DemandMap